| Dick Ellsworth - Cubs (9-20 in 1962, 22-10 in 1963) | Murry Dickson - Pirates (20-16 in 1951, 14-21 in 1952) |
| Wilbur Wood - White Sox (24-20 in 1973, 20-19 in 1974) | Larry Jackson - Cubs (24-11 in 1964, 14-21 in 1965) |
| Randy Jones - Padres (8-22 in 1974, 20-12 in 1975) | Mel Stottlemyre - Yankees (20-9 in 1965, 12-20 in 1966) |
| Luis Tiant - Indians (21-9 in 1968, 9-20 in 1969) | |
| Steve Carlton - Phillies (27-10 in 1972, 13-20 in 1973) | |
| Stan Bahnsen - White Sox (21-16 in 1972, 18-21 in 1973) | |
| Wilbur Wood - White Sox (24-17 in 1972, 24-20 in 1973) | |
| Wilbur Wood - White Sox (20-19 in 1974, 16-20 in 1975) | |
| Jerry Koosman - Mets (21-10 in 1976, 8-20 in 1977) |